• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Texas Gop Critical Thinking

The question of how extreme is too extreme for Texas Republican voters may be answered on Tuesday evening, when voters are expected to favor a woman who believes that Barack Obama was a drug-addicted male prostitute, in an election that could put her on the brink of one of the most influential positions in the state’s education system.

Even amid the roiling rhetoric and outrageous claims that have infected American politics in recent months, Mary Lou Bruner has provided some standout soundbites that have surfaced during her bid to win her district’s Republican nomination for a place on the Texas state board of education.

She wrote last October: “Obama has a soft spot for homosexuals because of the years he spent as a male prostitute in his twenties. That is how he paid for his drugs. ”

Federal pre-kindergarten programmes, she has argued, are a plot to make children confused about their sexuality: “The federal government wants to indoctrinate the little children, teaching them a homosexual marriage is just as good as a marriage with a father and a mother.”

Bruner has also suggested on social media that John F Kennedy was killed by the Democratic party “because the socialists and Communists in the party did not want a conservative president”, that climate change is a hoax invented by Karl Marx, the “USA should ban Islam”, and that humans and dinosaurs walked Earth simultaneously, and dinosaurs died out because only babies were carried on the Ark, so they were too young to reproduce on a barren planet after the flood.

“The things that she said are demonstrably false, incredibly offensive and deeply divisive and yet she’s the front-runner,” said Dan Quinn of the Texas Freedom Network, a watchdog that captured many of Bruner’s social media posts before they were withdrawn from public view after attracting media attention.

“That’s remarkable when you think about the state the size of Texas, with an economy the size that we have, and the influence that we have around the rest of the country … It makes us look like a backwater.”

Texas is the US’s second-most populous state and has more than 5 million children enrolled in public schools. Its education system has long been influential beyond its borders because its textbooks have been used in other parts of the country, though that practice is declining now that technology is making it easier for publishers to tailor content to specific states.

The Texas board has become a notorious cultural battleground in recent years as an increasingly conservative membership sought to stamp their ideological values on textbooks, including emphasising religion’s role in the founding of the US and expressing scepticism about climate change.

Bruner has not retracted her claims. In response to a request for comment, her husband directed the Guardian to an appearance on WFAA local news last Sunday. “When I wrote those things I wasn’t even intending to run for the state board of education,” she said.

“These are not conspiracies, you can look them up on the internet now. You can Google One World Order [a one-government conspiracy theory] or you can Google Agenda 21 [a non-binding United Nations resolution on sustainable development].

“The government doesn’t even try to hide these things now, it is a plan … climate change – they’ve made us think that it’s caused by man-made actions, and most of the people that I talk to just don’t believe that we’re causing it. They believe that it’s cyclical, even weathermen on the TV channels have come out and said that there are cycles.”

She is standing in district 9, which comprises 31 mostly rural counties in east Texas, some near Dallas. If elected, from January she will be one of 15 board members who meet about five times a year to set policies and standards and choose textbooks used in Texas public schools. Currently, five members are Democrats and 10 are Republicans.

The 69-year-old retired teacher was only 2% shy of sealing the GOP candidacy outright in March, winning 48% of the vote ahead of her opponent on Tuesday, Keven Ellis, a 45-year-old chiropractor and local school board member, with 31%.

The general election is in November and is almost certain to be a formality for whoever is the candidate. Republicans’ dominance in Texas means that GOP primary elections, in which candidates typically pander to a highly conservative base that is a small fraction of the overall electorate, are all-important.

Leading politicians have also weighed in to link hot-button Republican topics with education and question the separation of church and state. In 2013, Greg Abbott – then the state’s attorney general, now its governor – posted a picture of a Bible and a gun on his Facebook page with the slogan: “Two things every American should know how to use … neither of which are taught in schools.”

Pressure also comes from organisations such as Truth in Textbooks, a rightwing grassroots group that began in 2013 and is expanding from Texas into North Carolina. It aims to mobilise hundreds of citizens who “find material in the social studies classrooms to be less than accurate”, to review textbooks and push publishers into making changes that range from basic factual corrections to the language used in references to Islam.

Texas textbooks hit the headlines last year when a social media post by a Houston-area mother (unaffiliated to the group) went viral and prompted the publisher McGraw-Hill to revise a passage in a geography textbook that described slaves as immigrant “workers”.

Bruner would not be the first member elected to the board to express some distinctly debatable views about the US president.

Cynthia Dunbar, an attorney, wrote a book in 2008 that claimed that a rise in socialism at the expense of Christian leadership was creating “striking” similarities between modern-day America and Germany shortly before the Holocaust. She followed it up with an article for a Christian website that implied Obama was a terrorist sympathiser waiting for an attack so he could declare martial law.

Open about homeschooling her own children, Dunbar was nonetheless elected to the board overseeing the state’s public schools in 2006 and served a four-year term. Last year she was named a state leader for Virginia for the Texas senator Ted Cruz’s ill-starred presidential campaign.

Textbooks, which are assigned and shared, in a classroom at Hutto High School in Hutto, Texas, April 5, 2012. (Photo: Ben Sklar / The New York Times)The Republican Party of Texas has issued their 2012 political platform and has come out and blatantly opposed critical thinking in public schools throughout the state. If you wonder what took them so long to actually state that publicly, it is really a matter of timing. With irrationality now the norm and an election hovering over the 2012 horizon, the timing of the Republican GOP announcement against "critical thinking" instruction couldn't be better.  It helps gin up their anti-intellectual base.

The Texas GOP's declarative position against critical thinking in public schools, or any schools, for that matter, is now an official part of their political platform. It is public record in the Republican Party of Texas 2012 platform. With regard to critical thinking, the Republican Party of Texas document states: "Knowledge-Based Education - We oppose the teaching of Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) (values clarification), critical thinking skills and similar programs that are simply a relabeling of Outcome-Based Education (OBE) (mastery learning) which focus on behavior modification and have the purpose of challenging the student's fixed beliefs and undermining parental authority." (page 20, Republican Party of Texas, 2012).

Yes, challenging beliefs or claims is considered insubordinate, immoral and could lead to rebellion, disobedience or perhaps worse: revolution. For the Republican Party and their followers, thinking is subversive, imagination is a sin and the Republican Party in Texas and elsewhere is working to codify this into public policy. The plutocrats can't have a working-class citizenry that is asking questions of those in power, be they parents or bosses; instead, the people must be taught the ideology of what is morally acceptable, what rules and regulations to follow. and even more importantly, how to accept and internalize hierarchical authoritarianism. Critical thinking is a direct challenge to the "leaders" and their claims on authority, and any opposition to vertical arrangements is ethically unacceptable to those in power.

Reactionaries have long known that enshrining ignorance and hierarchy in both thought and practice within the school curriculum is essential if the control of young minds is to be accomplished softly and quietly yet profoundly through propaganda and perception management. In the quarters of obedience training, "education" has nothing to do with "schooling" under capitalism.

Read more:The Public Intellectual

This thinking is not new. The ideological underpinnings for such repugnant beliefs sorrowfully tread back throughout the history of the 20th century and undoubtedly before. William Bagley's book, "Classroom Management," published in 1907 and widely used as a teacher-training manual throughout America in the early 1900s, was so highly praised at the time that it went through 30 printed editions. The book echoed the morbid thinking of many so-called Gilded Age educators at the time. One such passage from the book sums up the thinking regarding children and childhood: "One who studies educational theory aright can see in the mechanical routine of the classroom the educative forces that are slowly transforming the child from a little savage into a creature of law and order, fit for the life of civilized society."

Law and order is what counts, and critical education, of course, seeks to subject all laws and claims to order to the lens of critical scrutiny, something the powerful disdain. Schooling under the neofeudalistic capitalist relations that are now emerging in the new Gilded Age of the 21st century is no different than in the past, where learning how not to think critically was the norm. The Texas GOP is simply creating the new conditions for a technological form of Plato's Cave with zero tolerance and the school-to-prison pipeline.

The Republican Party platform gets worse when it comes to prohibiting thinking critically about science or the scientific method. Take the section on " controversial theories," found on page 20:

Controversial Theories - We support objective teaching and equal treatment of all sides of scientific theories. We believe theories such as life origins and environmental change should be taught as challengeable scientific theories subject to change as new data is produced. Teachers and students should be able to discuss the strengths and weaknesses of these theories openly and without fear of retribution or discrimination of any kind.

Alternative beliefs such as creationism are now cleverly invited into the curriculum as so-called science or theories to debunk the purportedly false notions of the theory of evolution. But if critical thinking is not to be used in the classroom, how would these beliefs be examined for evidence? Science, the scientific method, critical thinking and the process of subjecting claims to evidentiary experimentation - all related activities - pose a threat to self-proclaimed power and the harbingers of supernaturalism.

IDEA Public Schools

One of the purveyors of such rubbish is Texas educational retail chain IDEA Public Schools. IDEA is a retail charter outfit that standardizes curriculum downwards, away from critical thinking, embracing instead rote memorization and regurgitation, or what I call the "anorexic/bulimic" learning model of intellectual atrophy, ossification, and decay.

IDEA is a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization. This status was obtained for tax purposes, and it would take another article to demonstrate how nonprofit status has been hijacked by special interests (charter schools in this case) in the interest of profit extraction.  In fact, IDEA Public Schools is public only because it takes public subsidies to stay alive.

IDEA's board members include representatives from JPMorgan, Teach for America, International Bank of Commerce, Wells Fargo and other Wall Street banking concerns. In spite of the fact that the board of IDEA is filled with Wall Street banking interests, IDEA says it works to assure students get what they call a "core curriculum." Critical thinking is never mentioned in the IDEA core curriculum - let alone entertained in IDEA classrooms, either by faculty or students; instead, IDEA is devoted to turning education into a commodity, students into customers mounted with saddlebags for tax funds that subsidize IDEA and turn schools into fortresses of profit.

According to IDEA's online blurb, the company is all about growth and expansion using taxpayer monies to grease the wheel: "In addition to its exemplary academic achievement, IDEA is moving forward with growth and expansion efforts to help serve more students throughout the Valley and Central Texas. IDEA currently enrolls over 9,000 students, with campuses in ten communities throughout the Rio Grande Valley. When all IDEA schools are at full scale (serving students in K-12th grade), IDEA will serve 15,000 from communities throughout the Rio Grande Valley." 

The company is moving across the Texas prairie, taking down traditional public schools like locusts consuming wheat fields. Keeping with the Republican platform, they promise to make obedience training and anti-intellectualism the cornerstone and foundation of education in Texas, to the detriment of students and society.

The Age of Irrationality and the Abdication of Reason

In the case of the Texas Republican Party, they have really upped the stakes. Supernaturalism and supernatural beliefs no doubt will continue to snake their way into public school lesson plans, and as Texas will have significant impact on the content of all the nation's texts through its textbook purchasing power, we may find that the tale of the Loch Ness Monster is now told to children as if it were a true story in science classes. Don't laugh! This is now the case in Louisiana where, as The Washington Post reported, "A biology textbook used by a Christian school in Louisiana that will be accepting students with publicly funded vouchers in the fall says that the Loch Ness Monster in Scotland is real. And it isn't just any monster but a dinosaur - an effort to debunk evolution and bolster creationist theory."

Remember: In Louisiana, taxpayer money is given in the form of school vouchers so that parents can now see their tax monies spent on a supernatural curriculum bent on teaching that the Loch Ness Monster and other fairy tales are true.

All of this can be seen as part and parcel of the emerging Age of Irrationality, the hemorrhaging of a post-literate society where reason is abdicated in favor of irrationality and appeals to supernaturalism. The sad part is that all of this is now encouraged, by forces bent on enslaving the minds of children, as the new "curriculum circus" in schools.

In the New Digital Dark Ages, where the landscape is packed with scurrilous corporate politicians on the take, textbook companies clawing for educational profits, and tent preachers looking for a congregation of sheep-le and a quick Elmer Gantry buck, the people who suffer are students, teachers and the average citizen.

It Doesn't Stop There

Prohibitions against thinking critically or scientifically comprise just one of 30 pages of the anti-Enlightenment thinking seen in the Texas GOP platform document. Here is some more of its chilling content:

  •  Abstinence-only sex education
  • Trying juveniles as adults
  • Emphasis on faith-based drug rehab
  • Opposition to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child
  • Flat-rate income tax
  • Repeal of the minimum wage
  • Opposition to homosexuality in the military
  • Opposition to red light cameras
  • Opposition to the Employment Non-Discrimination Act, because firms should be able to fire people for what they consider "sinful and sexually immoral behavior."
  • Continued opposition to ACORN (even though it has not existed since 2010!)
  • Opposition to statehood or even Congressional voting rights for the citizens of the District of Columbia
  • And no-questions-asked support for Israel because, and this is another direct quote: "Our policy is based on God's biblical promise to bless those who bless Israel and curse those who curse Israel and we further invite other nations and organizations to enjoy the benefits of that promise."


This is corporate American culture and education today, or at least a great and growing part of it. Learning to identify assumptions and differentiating them from facts, questioning assumptions in light of evidence, engaging in wonder and inquiry, exchanging other points of view in an atmosphere of civility and inquiry (especially entertaining those points of view one does not agree with), learning the art of critical self reflection, asking for evidence for claims made by oneself and others, and testing hypotheses through the development of methods and protocols of thinking - opposition to all of this has emerged from the Texas GOP's "hidden curriculum" and is now under the magnifying glass of scrutiny - and secured a place in the Texas Republican platform.

This is not only a telling moment for a complex empire in spiraling decline, but also a frightening moment, for we can see evolution transformed into devolution and schools converted into the supernatural rabbit holes that lead to Alice-in-Wonderland gated communities of ignorance governed by a chilling hierarchy of totalitarianism and fear.


It says above that 'critical thinking is never mentioned in the IDEA curriculum." I erred, it is mentioned - but only as it applies to Humanities. It is not mentioned anywhere else in the curriculum:


The IDEA Public Schools Humanities curriculum is designed to teach students a variety of reading, writing and critical thinking skills that they will use throughout their secondary and post-secondary careers" (ibid).

With thanks to Meg Griffith, 12th Grade IB Math Teacher, 12th Grade Team Leader who brought this oversight to my attention.

Copyright, Truthout. May not be reprinted without permission.

One thought on “Texas Gop Critical Thinking

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *